Nominations for the 2027 HRTally Choice Awards close December 15. Every winner is chosen by verified user reviews, never by sponsorship. See how it works
Performance and development

Self-review request email template

Ask employees to complete a self-assessment with clear questions and a useful purpose.

HRTally Research Team
Updated October 15, 2026 · Written by US HR practitioners · Editorial standards

At a glance

  • Use it to: ask employees to complete a self-assessment with clear questions and a useful purpose.
  • When to send: Open self-reviews two to three weeks before manager reviews are due, with a one-week deadline and a reminder two days before.
  • Inside: 2 ready-to-edit versions (self-review request and short reminder), 5 subject lines, and a printable PDF.
  • Compliance: low legal risk, but check names, dates, and links before you send.

When to use this template

A good self-review helps employees reflect on their work and gives managers examples they may have missed. A bad one becomes a box-checking exercise or an anxious attempt to guess the right rating. The request email sets the tone. Tell people why it matters, what to include, how long to spend, and how the manager will use it.

Give employees a few concrete prompts. Results and examples are more useful than adjectives. Encourage them to include work that managers may not see, such as helping colleagues or fixing problems quietly. Pair this with the performance review reminder for managers.

Used often inTechnology

The email templates

Copy either version, replace everything in [brackets], and read it once out loud before you send it. If it doesn't sound like you, change it.

Version 1

Self-review request

SubjectYour self-review is due [Date]
Hi [Employee first name],

It's time for [Period] performance reviews. The first step is your self-review, due in [Tool] by [Date]. Plan for about [30 to 45] minutes.

Your self-review helps [Manager name] see your work the way you see it, including things they might have missed. Focus on:
1. Your two or three most important results this period, with specific examples
2. Something that didn't go as planned, and what you learned
3. What you want to develop or take on next
4. What support you need from your manager or the company

You don't need to rate yourself perfectly. Honest examples are more useful than polished language.

[HR contact or manager name]
Version 2

Short reminder

SubjectReminder: self-review due [Date]
Hi [Employee first name],

A reminder that your self-review is due on [Date] in [Tool]: [Link].

Need inspiration? Look back at your calendar, project updates, and any thank-you messages from colleagues for examples.

[HR contact]

Subject lines to try

The subject line decides whether the email is opened today or next week. Keep it specific and short enough to read on a phone.

  • Your self-review is due [Date]
  • Reminder: self-review due [Date]
  • Tell us about your [Period]
  • Time to reflect: your self-assessment
  • Self-reviews open today

How to personalize it

  • Limit the self-review to four or five questions.
  • Ask for examples, not adjectives.
  • Explain how the manager will use it.
  • Suggest sources for examples, such as calendars and project notes.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Asking employees to rate themselves without guidance.
  • Ignoring the self-review in the final review.
  • Requiring long essays.
  • Deadlines that fall during peak workload.

When to send it

Open self-reviews two to three weeks before manager reviews are due, with a one-week deadline and a reminder two days before. For seasonal businesses, avoid peak periods.

Before you hit send

Run through this quick check. It takes a minute and catches most of the mistakes that cause follow-up emails.

  • Feedback is tied to specific examples and dates, not personality.
  • Deadlines avoid peak workload periods and holidays.
  • Nonexempt employees can complete the task during paid time.
  • HR reviewed anything formal, such as a PIP, for timing and consistency.
  • Employees know how their input will be used.

Where to go from here

Templates fix one email. The right process and software fix the whole workflow.

Still learning

Read the guide

Weighing options

Automate emails like this

Ready to shortlist

Compare vendors and get quotes

Get free quotesTry AI Match

Frequently asked questions

Are self-reviews worth it?
Yes, when managers actually read and discuss them. They surface examples managers miss and give employees a voice in the process.
Should self-reviews include a rating?
Some companies ask for one. It can start a useful conversation, but many people underrate or overrate themselves, so treat it as input.
What if an employee doesn't complete a self-review?
The manager should still complete the review and discuss it. Note the missed step if it's part of the job expectations.

Written by the HRTally Research Team

Our guides are written and reviewed by people with hands-on US HR, payroll, and HR technology experience. Legal and tax facts are checked against primary sources, such as the Department of Labor, IRS, EEOC, and USCIS, and linked at the end of each guide. Vendors never review or pay for our editorial content.

Still sending HR emails by hand?

Compare HR software that automates candidate, onboarding, and employee emails, or get three matched options free.

Compare HR software